How to run a promotion that makes money, and prove it did
Set a goal and a cost limit, compare sales with a normal period, subtract the discount and check the weeks after. Count extra profit, not total sales.
A promotion pays off when the extra profit it brings in is more than the discount and ad costs, after you account for sales that would have happened anyway. To know whether yours did, compare it with a normal period of the same length, subtract what it cost, and check the weeks afterward for a dip. Plan that check before you launch, not after.
Why do so many promotions lose money?
Busy registers feel like success. But part of every promotion goes to customers who would have paid full price that week. Another part goes to people who just bought earlier than they would have, so the next few weeks run slow. Store-wide sales get hit hardest by both.
Discounts also cut deeper than they look. Example: an item sells for $50 and costs you $30, so your margin is $20 (40%). A 20% discount takes $10 off, which is half your profit. You need to sell twice as many just to earn the same.
How do you plan a promotion that pays?
- Pick one goal. Fill slow Tuesday afternoons, clear old stock, bring back lapsed customers or get first-time buyers. Each needs a different offer.
- Pick the group. A promotion sent to people who haven't visited in six months works harder than one sent to everyone. Targeting your marketing with customer data shows how to build those lists.
- Set the offer and a cost limit. Prefer offers that cost you less than they're worth to the customer: a free add-on, a bundle or a gift with purchase instead of a straight percentage off.
- Set an end date. A few days to two weeks.
- Use a code or a tracked link. A unique code per channel (email, text, flyer) tells you which one brought people in.
How do you measure the result?
Before launch, write down the numbers for a comparison period: the same weeks last year, or the average of the last four normal weeks. Then work it out:
| Step | Example |
|---|---|
| Sales during the promotion | $12,000 |
| Normal sales for the same period | $9,000 |
| Extra sales | $3,000 |
| Margin on extra sales at 40% | $1,200 |
| Discount given on all promo sales | $900 |
| Ad and printing costs | $150 |
| Profit from the promotion | $150 |
Example only. Then look at the two to four weeks after. If sales dropped below normal, subtract that too. In this example a small dip would wipe out the gain.
With a big enough list, you can test it more directly. Hold back a random slice of the customers you'd send the offer to and compare what they spend with the group that got it. Promotion software company Talon.One suggests holding back 10% to 20% as a starting point.
What should you do with the results?
Keep a simple log of every promotion: dates, offer, group, cost and the final profit number. After three or four, patterns show up, like which offers bring in new customers and which ones only discount your regulars.
Add the promotion's numbers to your weekly scorecard while it runs, so you can stop a losing offer early. Promotions also work best sent to people who asked to hear from you; email marketing for small businesses covers building that list.
We pull sales from your POS or accounting software and build promotion reports through our reports and customer data service.
Common questions
- How do you measure if a promotion was successful?
- Compare sales and profit during the promotion with a normal period of the same length, like the same weeks last year. Subtract the discount and any ad costs, then check the two to four weeks afterward for a dip. What's left is what the promotion earned.
- What is a good discount for a small business promotion?
- The smallest one that gets people to act. Run the math on your margin first. For example, a 20% discount on a 40% margin item gives away half your profit, so you'd need to roughly double sales of it to come out even.
- What kind of promotion works best for a small business?
- Ones aimed at a specific group and a specific slow time, like a weekday offer for lapsed customers. Store-wide sales mostly reward people who would have bought anyway.
- How long should a promotion run?
- Usually a few days to two weeks. Short windows create a reason to act now and limit the cost. Long-running discounts start to feel like the normal price.